Time to speak out.
Put it straight, Mikko Ronkko has coded the best CB add-on under the wrong license (property), encrypted the code, set up a paranoid licensing system, had some health issues about 5 months ago, apparently recovered from them and went on the loose ever since.
Personally, i have always found his behaviour a bit too childish regarding the license and its implementation, like a brat who's afraid to get his lollipop stolen.
More than once he has stated his dissatisfaction with the open source model by assuming that most folks do not contribute, which is true, but not valid as an argument. Each one contributes within the realm of his/her knowledge. My little company has contributed to Mikko's pocket a few months before APC became publicly available. Besides some cash, our main contribution back then was to report him bugs we have spotted here and there. Later on, when the extension was released as a closed source commercial extension, we bought a couple of licenses.
Finally, the one who breaches licensing policies and releasing ethics in the 1st place is Mikko himself. APC is a derivative of Joomla, built on the Joomla API (and the CB API as well). Without Joomla it can't do shit. Joomla, as you all know, is released under the GPL, which enforces certain compliance rules for derivative products. This is not exclusive to Mikko (i know of worse cases), nonetheless, and can be regarded as plain money making opportunism.
As a vendor, Mikko has been the most irresponsible one i have ever dealt with.
Unless he has been kidnapped by deers in Lapland since April, there's no excuse for his professional misconduct.
A shame, because the guy has got loads of talent and created a wonderful piece of software.
I still remember the times when he used to be helpful and responsive, whether paid or for free.
This said, i wish joomladevil.com the best of luck. You have my full (though modest) support and appreciation. Soon you can certainly count me among your steady subscribers (this is what Mikko failed to realize; it is possible to make some nice cash from FOSS). You guys took the step we have all been waiting for.
Nuno.
Post edited by: nzimas, at: 2008/08/11 09:42
The topic has been locked.