Lists - info appearing when not logged in

Hello.
I've created a list of registered users to be available to unregistered users. Specifically, our athletic club board members.
Now, when I access the public page and I'm not logged in, I can't read the names... and the names are shown only after I log in... What did I do wrong?
I want the general public (people without a valid login) to access this page and read everything...

The field needs to be accessible to the viewing user. This means whatever tab the field is on needs to be accessible as well. Review your tab view access levels for your fields and adjust as necessary to Public.