I evaluated Mamblog, JD-WordPress and Joomblog.
Mamblog:
This is the component that is being used in Joomlapolis, home of CB. However, it has the following weakness:
* Without much configuration, the blog layout looks ugly with my site template. Well, it also looks "scattering around" on Joomlapolis.
* It relies on external comment system such as AkoComment (I tested with Tweaked 1.1). Meaning developer has to take care of both configuration and to maintain 2 upgrade paths.
* Development of Mamblog is slow. Version 1 was released on 30 October 2005. Development of AkoComment is also slow or stop.
JD-WordPress:
Strangely this component is not listed on Joomla Extention anymore. But I still manage to download version 2.0 from Joomla SourceForge. Document can be found on
www.joomladeveloping.org
.
* However I am not able to evaluate further. I keep getting "No Authorized" error message on many links simply inside Joomla administration.
* It seems that JD-WordPress is for single user blogging only.
Joomblog:
Reading the past review, it seems Joomblog was lacking much functionality. I simply tested the newest Joomblog 2.3 RC2. To my surprise, I believe it has great enhancement.
* It comes with a well-thought and build-in Comment system, which works for both Joomla content and blog. The admin page allows you to enable which content to be commented. No need to worry about {moscomment}, much clever than AkoComment.
* It comes with a build-in guest book.
* It comes with a build-in rich text editor.
* It allows moderation of blogger, blog and comment.
* Blogging interface looks much nicer and more features than Mamblog. It allows public and private blog, publishing duration like Joomla content, Blogroll and Blogmail <- haha, dunno how it works but impressive.
* Plug-in works with CB. So you can have a Joomblog tab too.
* BlogSide module shows lastest blog, lastest comment, etc, all in one. Convinient. (Opps, it seems not functioning)
* Most importantly, multi-user blogging!
* ...
I think at this point of time (June 2006), Joomblog outshines the rest.